twistedxkiss wrote:
"I am in a very strange position because the typical accommodation is to simply not take math classes in college if you have dyscalculia."

What planet is this true on and how fast can I move there? ;)

From what I've been able to tell, some schools accept formula sheets as an accommodation, some don't. Neither of the schools I've attended allow it, which is part of why I didn't major in a math/science field. I hope someone here will have another suggestion. Have you met with the disabilities coordinator? What did they suggest?